Mick Abel tied the Phillies franchise record for strikeouts in an MLB debut with nine, and the Phillies hung on to win 1-0 Sunday afternoon in South Philly. Abel ties Curt Simmons’ 80-year-old record. Simmons was a key component of the “Whiz Kids,” who won the 1950 National League title. The win comes on the heels of Jose Alvarado’s 80-game PED suspension. With the win, Philadelphia completes a three-game sweep of the Pirates; they’ll head to Colorado to face the Rockies in a series starting Tuesday evening.
Mick Was More Than Abel
Abel threw only 84 pitches, allowed no walks, and scattered five hits across six frames. He displayed incredible poise with runners on base and outdueled superstar pitcher Paul Skenes. Abel and Skenes are both former first-round picks, but their journeys to the majors could not be more different. Skenes needed only one year to work through the Pirates’ farm system after being drafted in 2023, making his debut in May 2024.
Here’s every strikeout from Mick Abel’s scoreless debut.
— Luke Arcaini (@ArcainiLuke) May 18, 2025
9 strikeouts. 5 on the curveball, 1 on the slider, 2 on the fastball, and 1 on the sinker.
He didn’t walk one batter all day. pic.twitter.com/jxlIzhf7R9
Abel, drafted 15th overall in 2020, was once a top-50 prospect in the Phillies system, but struggled immensely in 2024. His ERA ballooned to 6.46 in Triple-A Lehigh Valley and fell out of the top 50 list. He’s been a completely different pitcher for the Iron Pigs this season, with a 2.53 ERA and 51 strikeouts across 46 innings.
“There were times where I didn’t think I would be, but there were other times where I would,” Abel said about his road the Major Leagues. “I think it’s just going through the ups and downs and trying to understand how to go through those. Thankfully I was able to think about it in the offseason and understand ‘Yeah, I’m still pretty good at baseball.”
Skenes (3-5) was fantastic on Sunday, but was once again a victim of the Pirates’ anemic supporting cast. He also had nine Ks to go along with a complete game. He allowed only three hits and one run off a Brandon Marsh sacrifice.

Skenes’ recent performances for an organization without interest in winning are a black eye for the sport. The MLB cannot wait for his eventual trade to a contender in a few years. Skenes looks too good in black and yellow, and why even have baseball in Pittsburgh if they can’t keep him? The League and the other owners need to step in and find new owners in Pittsburgh or fix baseball’s competition problem.
Phillies Eek Out Win, But Pitching Problems Loom
Abel was relieved in the seventh by Orion Kerkering, who needed some fantastic defensive plays from Trea Turner and Alec Bohm to get out of the inning. Matt Strahm and Jordan Romano closed out the eighth and ninth innings, respectively, with Romano striking out the side. The Phillies will need those bullpen pieces to continue producing if they have any hope of recovering from the loss of Alvarado.
End Of My Phillies Rant

Alvarado’s 80 suspension is completely crippling to a bullpen that was already the Phillies weak spot. Even if they add a closer like Ryan Helsley at the deadline, they will most likely have the worst bullpen in the postseason. The Phillies must start leveraging their younger arms. Taijuan Walker should stay in the bullpen; he has struggled as a starter, and most would feel more comfortable with a veteran learning to pitch out of the pen than a rookie. Abel should not be sent down; he is 23 years old, has spent almost 5 seasons in the farm system, and you must see if he can do the job.
The Phillies are famously reluctant to promote rookies to the big league club, but they no longer have that luxury. Pitcher Andrew Painter‘s promotion should come sooner rather than later as well. The Phillies’ window with the current roster is closing quickly, and after the moves made in Los Angeles and New York this offseason, their lineup is no longer as feared as it once was. What they do have is MLB-ready arms.
The Lehigh Valley Iron Pigs are the best Triple-A team in the minors. That is pretty silly for a Major League playoff contender. It’s time for Dave Dombroski and Rob Thompson to raid the Iron Pigs and see what sticks in the bullpen.