The Philadelphia Phillies were struck with a devastating blow yesterday after Major League Baseball announced that Jose Alvarado was suspended for 80 games due to a failed drug test.
Alvarado reportedly failed the drug test due to a weight-loss drug that contained a form of Testosterone.
The team issued a statement saying that they were “disappointed to hear today’s news of Jose’s violation.”
A team that has already had its fair share of bullpen problems this season now has to cope with the absence of its best reliever.
If they make it to the Postseason, the Venezuelan left-hander will also be ineligible for those games.
There are some options going forward, both internally and externally, and David Dombrowski now has some massive decisions to make.
Internal Options

The Phillies have several solid bullpen arms in Triple-A (AAA) this season, including Koyo Aoyagi, Brett de Geus, Nabil Crismatt, and Seth Johnson.
Aoyagi signed as an international free agent this past offseason and currently boasts a 3.97 ERA after giving up four runs in an outing, which inflated it from a 0.87.
For de Geus, he’s been an excellent bullpen arm for Lehigh Valley, currently pitching to an ERA under 2.00.
Crismatt and Johnson have spent time in the rotation and bullpen this season, and could be what the Phillies need.
Jose Ruiz will be back as well, with his rehab assignment with Lehigh Valley complete.
The most intriguing option could be Mick Abel. Abel made his debut for the Phillies when they faced off against Paul Skenes and the Pittsburgh Pirates.
After throwing six shutout innings with nine strikeouts and no walks, Abel looks to potentially be a key factor in the Phillies’ pitching staff.
If the Phillies choose to keep Abel in Philadelphia, he could slot into the rotation, allowing another starter to fit the role that Alvarado had.
With Abel in the rotation, Ranger Suarez or Taijuan Walker could take Alvarado’s spot. Walker would be the most realistic option when Nola comes off the 15-Day Injured List, as he’s been in the bullpen in his last two outings. Suarez has the most experience of the two when it comes to pitching out of the pen.
Out of all the internal options, the Phillies will need Jordan Romano to continue his recent success and clutch pitching.
After having a disastrous start to the 2025 campaign, the former All-Star Closer has improved his play immensely in the past two weeks.
Finally, Orion Kerkering could be given the opportunity to be the main closer. despite a rough start to the season. Matt Strahm could also be a lefty closer if he continues his better run of form.
External Options

If the Phillies decide to trade for a closer/reliever, there are certainly a good number of options out there.
The most notable name that has come up this season is St Louis’ Ryan Helsley. With the Cardinals playing better than expected this season, odds are Helsley would come with a high price tag in terms of value.
It would most likely take at least two top prospects to grab the former all-star right-hander.
Another option could be Pennsylvania native Mason Miller of the Athletics. One of the best closers in baseball, trading for Miller is easier said than done.
His return would include multiple prospects, and possibly even a Major League-level pitcher.
Up next is Lucas Erceg. Boasting a 0.47 ERA, the Kansas City Royals right-hander has been one of the best relievers in all of baseball this season.
For a left-hander, the Phils could turn to someone like the Pirates or the Miami Marlins. It may be too early to tell, but those two teams will likely sell at the trade deadline in July. Pittsburgh’s Ryan Borucki or Miami’s Andrew Nardi could provide the Phillies with a high-leverage left-handed reliever.
The last trade option could be David Bednar. He has certainly had his share of trouble over the last year and a half, but Dombrowski is known for acquiring pitchers who are struggling.
After what Jeff Hoffman did for the Phillies before his departure to Toronto, Bednar could be in a similar situation. Bednar’s return would be the least out of the three, only taking at least a single prospect.
Finally, David Robertson could be a fit with the Phils. Currently a free agent, Robertson spent parts of 2019 and 2022 with Philadelphia and appeared in many high-leverage situations during his time in red pinstripes.
End of Phillies Rant
Overall, the Phillies will need to make some tough decisions in the coming days to replace Jose Alvarado during his suspension. Not only will they need a reliever now, but they’ll also need a solid arm for the Playoffs, if they make it that far.
Alvarado has been Philadelphia’s best reliever this season, and arguably one of the best left-handed bullpen arms in the Major Leagues in 2025.
It’s a devastating loss, to say the least. A bullpen that has been quite shaky this season now goes into the rest of the season without its cornerstone player.
There are a multitude of options, both internally and externally, and it will be interesting to see what David Dombrowski has up his sleeve.