The New York Mets entered Saturday’s Subway Series matinee scuffling. They looked feeble in their last two games, losing 4-0 to the downtrodden Pittsburgh Pirates and 6-2 to the New York Yankees. The bats never got going, and Tylor Megill struggled with command against the Yankees in a game that was never competitive.

The Mets’ hitters stayed mired in a collective slump all week. They scored eight runs over their last four games.  They lost the power that carried the team throughout their strong early stretch, hitting only one. To their credit, they won two games relying on situational hitting and smart base running. Would they need to do more of the same Saturday?

Canning Continues To Be Free Agent Gold

General Manager David Stearns led the Mets’ most transformative offseason ever. He landed Juan Soto to a massive deal, resigned Sean Manaea, and restocked the bullpen. Lost in the dramatic transactions was the low-cost one-year signing of Griffin Canning. He came off an awful season, going 6-13 with a 5.19 earned run average for the Los Angeles Angels. Most saw the addition as a depth filler, nothing more.  

Stearns has emphasized pursuing cost-effective pitching that can benefit from the Mets’ pitching labs, analytics, and excellent pitching coach Jeremy Hefner. Last year, Luis Severino, Jose Quintana, and Manaea had strong seasons using these resources.  Stearns believed that rather than spending major money on 30-year-old-plus pitchers, it behooved the Mets to take flyers on arms like Canning.

Stearns’s strategy worked exceptionally well in 2024. It may have gotten even better in 2025 with Canning as the centerpiece. He has made the adjustments through the Mets’ strong analytical approach and given them quality pitching each start. Saturday against the loaded Yankees lineup, that continued.

Canning effectively worked through jams in the 4th and 5th while shutting down the clear AL MVP front-runner, Aaron Judge. Like Kodai Senga, Canning’s confidence increases the more tense the situation. He pitched 5 1/3 innings, giving up seven hits, two runs, and striking out four, allowing his team to break through.  

Mets Bullpen Shuts The Door

The Mets’ relief corps has had a rough couple of weeks filled with injuries and struggles with adjusting roles. A.J. Minter and Danny Young, two vital lefty specialists, were lost for the season. Closer Edwin Diaz fought through weeks of injuries and inconsistency, and setup arms Ryne Stanek and Max Kranick struggled after strong early starts.

The bullpen showed signs of a turnaround in the low-scoring wins over the Pittsburgh Pirates, helping the Mets to victory through exceptional small ball. Could they do the same against the Yankees?

The relief corps took over after Canning gamely fought through 5 1/3 tough innings. Huascar Brazoban entered with the score tied and the Yankees threatening to take the lead. He quickly squelched the fire, inducing two fielders’ choices to end the 6th inning.

Brazoban made quick work of the 7th inning, getting two groundouts and striking out Judge. He was a trade deadline pickup last year, and he struggled with inconsistency, making him a forgotten figure by many Mets fans. He has emerged as possibly the most valuable bullpen piece, pitching 26 2/3 innings, allowing 13 hits, 6 walks, and striking out 25. He has a sparkling 1.01 ERA, and his WHIP is a microscopic 0.71.

Reed Garrett picked up where Brazoban left off, holding the Yankees down in a tense 8th. He made things interesting, walking three batters and a hit, but inducing a double play and a lineout to close the inning.

Diaz came in for the 9th and shut the door with emphasis. Looking like his usual lights-out self, he struck out Austin Wells, got Ben Rice to line out, and struck out Judge in a thrilling ending. Diaz pitching dominantly is huge for the Mets, especially as they work through hitting struggles. The bullpen must help shorten the games, and no one will play a more vital role than he.

The Mets’ Big Three All Contribute To Victory

The Mets’ top of the order, consisting of Francisco Lindor, Soto, and Pete Alonso, drives the team’s success. Usually, they do so with impressive power displays and bountiful hits. This week, though, the slugging has dried up, and getting on base has proved trickier. Could they find a way against the Yankees when the HRs weren’t available?

Lindor, Soto, and Alonso all played key roles in the crucial 4th inning.  Down a run, Lindor led off with a walk. Soto then singled, followed by a single by Alonso, driving home Lindor.

Soto then used a brilliant baserunning move to get to third base. He used a walking lead on Clarke Schmidt to steal third base uncontested. This allowed Mark Vientos to drive him home on a sacrifice fly to give the Mets the lead.

The Yankees battled back to tie the game, which it remained going into the 9th. With one out, Luis Torrens drew a walk, followed by an infield hit and a hit by pitch, loading the bases. Lindor has been the Mets’ most effective clutch player since last year. He came through again, using effective situational hitting with a sacrifice fly to bring home Torrens. Diaz’s shutdown bullpen work did the rest.

End Of My Mets Rant

The Mets are amid a difficult stretch; they’ve played huge games against the Arizona Diamondbacks, St. Louis Cardinals, and Chicago Cubs. The Subway Series always tests the mettle of each player. Coming up next are the Boston Red Sox at Fenway and at home against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Manager Carlos Mendoza believes his team can play with anyone; they will get ample opportunity to prove him right.

Getting victories when not playing well is an encouraging sign of an excellent team. The Mets have gotten multiple wins this week when the hitting barely showed up. Excellent team chemistry, reliable starting pitching, and renewed bullpen excellence have opened the door. Winning in diverse ways will stand this team well down the stretch and in the anticipated playoff battles.