With just nine games remaining, the Utah Hockey Club has fallen out of contention for a playoff spot. Even if they win all nine games (doubtful), they will only have a 66% chance of winning the second wild-card position. At this point, there is a 99% chance that they will be eliminated from the playoffs in their initial season in Utah.

So, what went wrong?

Utah Hockey Club’s Failures

When you examine the reason for a playoff spot not happening, it’s easy to blame it on injuries. After all, losing two first-line defensemen like Sean Durzi and John Marino to injuries was devastating. They also were without star forward Dylan Guenther, who was injured for 12 games. Injuries are certainly a part of the game, yet this team’s erratic performance must take some blame.

Over the 2024-25 season, the team has only two three-game winning streaks and one four-game streak. In contrast, they have dropped five games consecutively twice, three games three times, and four games once. Without consistency, a team’s aspirations of post-season play are greatly diminished.

Taking a look at the Utah Hockey Club’s play against playoff-level teams defines their lack of consistency. They have played 49 games against teams currently in a playoff spot or close to it. In those games, their record is 17-25-7. That equals a .418 points percentage. That won’t allow a team fighting for a post-season gig too much of a shot of getting there.

Goaltending Has Been Improved

Karel Vejmelka has improved substantially over his last season with the Arizona Coyotes. His record in Arizona as a backup to Connor Ingram was 13-19-2 with a dismal .895 save percentage and a 3.35 goals-against average. This season thus far, he has a 21-20-7 record with a respectable .903 save percentage and an excellent 2.60 GAA. With those statistics, he earned the starter role over Ingram. On March 9th, Ingram entered the NHL/NHLPA Player Assistance Program. That has meant that Vejmelka has started back-to-back games at times.

Karel Vejmelka

The Utah Hockey Club has decided Vejmelka is their goalie of the future, as they signed him to a five-year, $4.75 million AAV deal on March 5, 2025. Who the backup will be is still unknown. They have Jaxson Stauber, who has participated in six games with a 2-1-1 record. They sent Stauber to the AHL Tucson Roadrunners on Friday and recalled Matt Villata. That may be a sign of the team wanting to get a look at Villata at NHL level play.

The Future Looks Bright

For a displaced team who had to adjust to major off-ice changes moving from Arizona, they have done pretty well. They have a nucleus of talented young players. Clatyon Keller, their captain is leading his team again in scoring with 24 goals, 54 assists. The downside is he is a -11 in his +/- statistic meaning he has been on the ice 11 more times when his team allows a goal. He also has 70 giveaways ranking him sixth in that category.

Going down the list, Nick Schmaltz has 17 goals, 40 assists. His goal scoring tapered off this season, but his assists increased. He too is a -11 with 84 giveaways, placing him fourth on the team.

Logan Cooley, who could very well be the center of the future for the Utah Hockey Club has had another good year. He has 21 goals, 33 assists this season. One note with his statistics is he has been a +1 while having 60 giveaways.

Logan Cooley, Utah Hockey Club

Dylan Guenther has been the team’s leading goal scorer with 26. He signed a lucrative seven-year $7.14 millon AAV deal that will kick in next season. Without a doubt this Edmonton, Alberta native has what it takes to be an impact player for years to come. His power play abilities are off the chart. His 12 extra-man advantage goals leads the team. When he sets up near the faceoff circle for a one-timer it is reminicent of Alex Ovechkin.

Playoffs Next Season?

With the near success of gaining the playoffs this season, the Utah Hockey Club will have a much better shot at getting into the post-season for the 2025-26 season. This is still a relatively young team that will mature every new season. While this season has shown progress, there are things that need to be addressed.

Some players have not performed up to expectations. Take Lawson Crouse. He has had an absolutely horrible season, with only 10 goals and five assists in 72 games. This while he tallied 20 or more goals for the last three seasons in Arizona. Something is up with him and while he presents a physical presence with 170 hits this season, his playing time has decreased due to his ineffectiveness scoring. Look for him to be involved in trade rumors this summer. He has two more years on this $4.3 million deal and could be dealt away. Many teams could be attracted to his size and physicality.

Another player who could be gone is Matias Maccelli. His output this season has decreased with only eight goals and ten assists. He was a healthy scratch for 13 games and was the target of trade rumors before the trade deadline. He was not dealt, but depending on his performance in the last nine games, he could also be gone.

End Of Utah Hockey Club Rant

There were various reasons why the Utah Hockey Club didn’t make the playoffs. They will no doubt attempt to make adjustments to improve. For now, for all intensive purposes they are done this season.