The Cincinnati Reds have just traded for third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes from the Pittsburgh Pirates. With much speculation surrounding this team and the trade deadline, this move comes on the heels of a hungry team and fan base. 

Is this a trade that will move the needle for this team? After all, it does essentially guarantee that Eugenio Suarez will end up somewhere else. Here’s a look at why this Hayes trade pushes the Reds into contention. 

Hayes Fit With The Reds

Reds
Jul 22, 2025; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Pirates third baseman Ke’Bryan Hayes (13) high-fives in the dugout after scoring against the Detroit Tigers during the second inning at PNC Park. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

This season, Hayes is batting .236 with 87 hits, including 10 doubles, 10 steals, two triples, and two home runs. While it’s not the power bat some fans were hoping for, he will provide more contact and speed on the basepaths, which will fit in perfectly with the way this team is playing. 

Hayes is a career .254 hitter and will certainly be an improvement over players like Santiago Espinal or Will Benson, who, although going on hot streaks, struggle with extended slumps. Cincinnati thrives when everyone is putting the ball in play and running aggressively, so no matter where he’s slotted in the lineup, he will benefit both the guys in front of and behind him. 

Hayes is a defensive stud, too, winning a Gold Glove in 2023 and posting a .986 fielding percentage this year. The lowest fielding percentage he’s ever posted was in 2022, and he still finished with a league-leading .972. 

While defense at third base isn’t a priority for this team, it’s always welcome, especially considering the benefits at the plate. These positives suggest that the Reds should be able to climb the hump that is the wild card consideration, but was the cost of this new addition too high?

Who Did Cincinnati Give Up?

Reds
Jul 13, 2025; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Reds manager Terry Francona (77) walks on the field during a pitching change in the sixth inning against the Colorado Rockies at Great American Ball Park. Mandatory Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

In this trade, the Reds traded away reliever Taylor Rodgers and shortstop prospect Sammy Stafura. By all accounts, Cincinnati won this trade. 

Rodgers posted a 2.40 ERA over 40 games this season. This seems good on paper, but he had a tendency to make very messy situations even messier, and thus worked himself out of the regular rotation. 

Stafura is an impressive prospect, batting .262 with 18 doubles and nine triples. The Reds’ farm system, however, is loaded with players at the position. Taking away nothing from Stafura’s talent, moving on from him doesn’t impact the trajectory of this team whatsoever. 

Neither of these guys is a serious contributor to this team, and Cincinnati just added a player whose playstyle inevitably will. The positives of bringing Hayes in negate any negatives from sending these players away. 

End Of My Reds Ke’Bryan Hayes Rant 

Adding another contact bat with speed will certainly help this lineup with what they do best, steadily chipping away at a pitcher’s command. The fact that on the flip side of that is one of the better defensive players at the position is nice, too. 

This acquisition of Hayes no doubt will help Cincinnati on both sides of the ball and alleviate the mistakes on the margins that this team struggles with. It’s a move that adds real substance while removing fluff, and is a rare example of the front office listening to the team and its fans. 

The Reds are only three games back from the wild card spot, and this trade should push them over the line and into serious contention. Hayes looks to join the team ahead of their series against the Atlanta Braves, culminating with the Speedway Classic in Bristol, Tennessee.