EA Sports NHL 25 has been out for a few months, garnering mixed reviews among players. Like all video games, there is always a list of pros and cons; however, sports can receive even more scrutiny because of their yearly releases. While the game is impressive in some aspects, it is highly disappointing in others.

Franchise Mode

The revamped franchise mode was a major selling point for NHL 25. It featured a streamlined and cleaner menu and access to more statistics and box scores. NHL 25 also expanded the player/coach conversation system, which adds the ability to “convince” free agents to join your team and boost your players’ ratings, add X-factor abilities, and even change players’ playstyles. This also featured new contract options such as no trade or movement clauses.

My Take- The Good

Personally, this is the mode that I play the most. So far, I have found franchise mode exceedingly enjoyable. Having conversations with your players and coaches adds an element to realism and brings personality to your players. Furthermore, having to “convince” potential free agents to join your team using the conversation system has been particularly satisfying.

The new contract clauses have been on fans’ wish lists for years. This was a welcome addition to a contract negotiation that added an extra boost to authenticity. I also like that it makes it more difficult to “cheese” the system where a Columbus Blue Jackets GM could potentially make an unrealistic trade, bringing in Connor McDavid.

Moreover, the streamlined hub has made it much easier to navigate through the various menus, saving minutes. Another much-needed addition was the introduction of box scores and basic analytics. In previous years, if you accidentally sim through a bunch of games, you could feel out of the loop. Now, you can track box scores, how well players play against a particular team, and more. There was no excuse that this feature was not in the game several years ago.

My Take- The Bad

Despite the upgrades to franchise mode, scouting is still as messy as ever. The user interface is not very intuitive and under-explained. The game lacks guidance on how to scout perspective draft picks, leaving players to figure out the best strategies on their own.

Similarly, player attribute ratings are poorly explained. Gamers need to know precisely what each attribute does to utilize the player on the ice properly. Furthermore, this helps gamers make an educated decision on their trades and free-agent signings.

Player development is possibly the worst aspect of franchise mode. There is no guidance on how to grow a prospect, which leaves gamers in the dark about rebuilding their teams. Also, prospect development seems semi-random and disallows players from implementing a trial-and-error strategy, which only adds to the frustration.

Overall, the Franchise mode needs a comprehensive guide, fully functional tool tips, and UI. It is perplexing why an AAA developer has not released a comprehensive guide or clear tool tips for a game mode that demands extensive planning for future seasons.

Be-A-Pro Mode

Although NHL 25 received significant Franchise Mode improvements, Be-a-Pro mode has been hung out to dry. The mode itself is not bad, but it’s boring; a gamer may lose interest after a few hours. Giving it role-playing characteristics (such as NBA 2k or MLB the Show) would help.  More interactions with coaches, teammates, and opponents would add a fresh new aspect to outdated game mode. This is in dire need of an upgrade.

On-Ice Gameplay

The on-ice gameplay is the most important and obvious aspect of the NHL games. Despite the introduction of the new ICE-Q feature, the game does not feel too different from NHL 24. The only noticeable difference is the new one-timer system.

These days, where skill-based one-timer goals are commonplace, introducing this update adds to the realism. However, it has received mixed reactions, with some players insisting that creating a one-timer opportunity and scoring was far too easy.

On-Ice Presentation

NHL 25 is the first year EA has focused solely on new-generation consoles. Graphically, there have been some decent updates as well as more player facial scans, however gamers have been disappointed in the lack significant upgrades to ambiance of the during a game.

Although the broadcast presentation has received an update with the new grudge match system, it sorely needs an overhaul. The commentary has become repetitive and buggy. There is often dead air during replays and cutscenes or wrong analysis. The game could benefit from an overhaul, possibly modeling it after real-world broadcasts like TNT or TSN. Taking a page from MLB The Show or NBA 2k could lead to a major improvement if implemented correctly.

Along with the commentary, the condensed broadcasts and lack of cutscenes significantly reduce in-game immersion. Without cutscenes, the game feels less like an actual broadcast and more like a video game.

In short, the on-ice presentation can be summed up in a simple “meh”.

End Of My NHL 25 Rant

Although the game is an improvement from NHL 24, it still needs work. Franchise mode players will find the revamp entertaining and refreshing despite minor bugs and the poorly explained mechanics. Despite the improvements, the stale presentation takes away draw to this year’s installment.

Overall, the game is worth $20-$25 USD. Paying a full $70 may lead to disappointment.

Check out our hockey section for more in depth analysis!