The Colts finally have something to celebrate after snapping their five-game losing streak with a 24-22 victory over the Miami Dolphins. With that being said, Sunday’s victory shouldn’t overshadow the concern surrounding head coach Shane Steichen and his handling of the quarterback position.
Daniel Jones once again failed to establish consistency, throwing just 108 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions. One of those interceptions was returned for a touchdown by rookie cornerback Chris Johnson. Despite the disappointing performance, Jones remains the centerpiece of Steichen’s offense.

Steichen’s unwavering confidence in Jones raises an uncomfortable question about his leadership: Why hasn’t Daniel Jones faced the same level of scrutiny that Anthony Richardson experienced during his time as the Colts’ starting quarterback?
Richardson certainly had his shortcomings, but the standards applied to him appeared considerably different. Meanwhile, Jones has seemingly been afforded a longer leash despite mounting evidence that the Colts need to reconsider their direction under center.

Shane Steichen’s Double Standard at Quarterback
There is no denying Richardson struggled during his time as Indianapolis’ starting quarterback. His accuracy, decision-making, and ability to consistently execute the offense were legitimate concerns.
Yet, those struggles also became the defining conversation surrounding his development. Every missed throw, questionable decision, and inconsistent performance seemed to add another layer of pressure.
Steichen ultimately benched Richardson in October 2024 after the quarterback voluntarily removed himself from a game against Houston because of fatigue. The decision was presented as an opportunity for Richardson to develop, but it also marked a significant turning point in his relationship with the starting job.
The problem isn’t that Steichen expected more from Richardson. That’s part of being an NFL head coach. The problem is that those expectations haven’t been consistent.
Jones has experienced plenty of the same problems that ultimately contributed to Richardson losing his starting position. Inaccurate throws, turnovers, and an inability to consistently move the football have become increasingly difficult to ignore.
Sunday’s performance against Miami was another example. Jones posted a 1.7 quarterback rating against the Dolphins, the worst of the season for a quarterback.
Even so, Steichen immediately reaffirmed his commitment to Jones. At what point does that commitment become a coaching problem?

Richardson Never Received the Same Patience
Richardson entered the NFL as a developmental quarterback with extraordinary physical tools but limited experience as a starter. The Colts knew that when they selected him fourth overall in the 2023 NFL Draft.
His development was never going to be an overnight process. Nevertheless, Steichen’s handling of Richardson increasingly suggested that mistakes would come with immediate consequences. Richardson needed to demonstrate improvement, but he also needed the opportunity to make those improvements through consistent playing time.
Instead, Indianapolis eventually turned to veteran quarterback Joe Flacco in 2024. There were understandable reasons for the decision. Richardson wasn’t playing well enough, and the Colts were attempting to remain competitive in a division race. Still, the organization’s approach raised questions about whether it was genuinely committed to developing its young quarterback.
Fast-forward to Jones, and the contrast becomes difficult to overlook. Jones entered the circle city with considerably more NFL experience. He also arrived with an established history of inconsistency throughout his professional career.
Steichen seemed to believe he could revive the quarterback’s career, and early results offered some encouragement. But that doesn’t mean Jones should be exempt from criticism when those same problems resurface. Richardson was expected to prove himself every Sunday. Jones should face the same expectations.

Sunday’s Victory Doesn’t Change The Colts’ Reality
Indianapolis needed Sunday’s victory, especially after five consecutive losses and a disastrous stretch that included a 42-7 defeat against Jacksonville. On the other hand, there is a difference between winning a football game and demonstrating meaningful improvement.
The Colts finished with 172 rushing yards, including 83 from Jonathan Taylor and 77 from rookie Seth McGowan. Their defense also provided a crucial touchdown when Adetomiwa Adebawore recovered a fumble in the end zone. Those contributions were instrumental in securing the victory.
Jones, meanwhile, struggled to provide much offensive production. His two interceptions and inability to consistently complete passes beyond the line of scrimmage left Indianapolis depending on its defense and running game. There were also 13 penalties, several of which prevented the Colts from putting Miami away earlier.
This wasn’t the type of performance that should inspire unquestioned confidence in the quarterback position. Steichen deserves credit for getting his team through a difficult afternoon and ending the losing streak.
Even so, the head coach also deserves scrutiny for the offensive product he continues putting on the field. A victory doesn’t automatically make every coaching decision correct.

End Of My Shane Steichen Rant
The Colts have experienced plenty of organizational turmoil throughout the season. Indianapolis has traded away several important players, watched its season spiral out of control, and reached a point where the future of the franchise looks considerably different than it did just months ago.
That makes Steichen’s responsibilities even more important. He needs to establish an identity for this football team, and that starts with accountability.
Jones shouldn’t receive preferential treatment because of his experience or the organization’s investment in him. If the coaching staff expects its quarterback to protect the football, execute the offense, and consistently produce results, those expectations must apply regardless of who is under center.
Richardson wasn’t perfect. Nobody should pretend otherwise. Despite this, the Colts cannot continue applying different standards to different quarterbacks while expecting the same results.
Steichen was brought to Indianapolis to develop quarterbacks and build an effective offense. His reputation as an offensive-minded coach helped make him an attractive candidate when the organization hired him in 2023. Three seasons later, Indianapolis still has significant questions about the most important position in football.
Sunday’s victory was a welcome change from the embarrassment of the previous five weeks. However, the underlying problems haven’t disappeared.
If Steichen genuinely believes Jones gives Indianapolis its best opportunity to win, he needs to demonstrate that belief through consistent offensive production. Otherwise, the head coach risks becoming just as responsible for the Colts’ quarterback problems as the players themselves.