According to national baseball experts, the Milwaukee Brewers were supposed to take a step backward in 2025. Coming off a National League Central title in 2024 to make the playoffs for the sixth time in seven years, prognosticators felt the Brew Crew’s division reign had reached the end.
Back in March, ESPN predicted that the Brewers would fail to reach the .500 mark in 2025, forecasting their record to be 80-82. CBS Sports was a bit more optimistic, setting Milwaukee’s over/under for wins at 83.5. Neither outlet felt that they were destined for postseason play.
Not so fast, friends.
The Brewers have surpassed expectations through the first three months of the season. As of July 1, their record stands at 47-37, good for second place in the NL Central, just two games out of first. If they maintain this pace, Milwaukee is on track for 90.7 wins, which would far exceed what the “experts” prophesied.
In an incredibly curious twist, that aforementioned ESPN article cited three different variables the Brewers needed to come true for a successful October run. Up to this point in the season, those suggestions are spot on.
ESPN Article Saw Into The Future
ESPN writer Alden Gonzalez previewed the Brewers’ 2025 season back in March. He felt Milwaukee was the 15th-best team in baseball and had a 28.9% chance of reaching the postseason.
Gonzalez concluded his article with a paragraph entitled, “How They Can Be An October Threat.” He did not know how prescient he now is.
Gonzalez wrote: “The Brewers need more of what Christian Yelich displayed before season-ending back surgery — a .909 OPS, his highest mark in five years, and 11 homers in 73 games — but they also need to adequately replace the stars who departed. That means Joey Ortiz, (Willy) Adames’ replacement at shortstop, needs to take a step forward in his age-26 season. And Trevor Megill will have to step up in a closer’s role once held by (Devin) Williams.”
All three have happened in the first half of the season. Here is a closer look.
Christian Yelich Has Returned To Form For The Brewers
After winning the 2018 NL MVP and having an even better 2019 season cut short because of injury, Christian Yelich had not regained the superior production that Brewers fans came to expect. From 2021 through 2023, Yelich’s numbers were pedestrian at best. He never hit more than 19 home runs in a season over that span, and his batting average never threatened the .320-plus level of 2018 and 2019.
His 2024 campaign started promising and garnered him a spot on the NL All-Star team in July. However, he managed to play in only 74 total games because of a season-ending back injury. With no guarantees on how the surgery would fare, Yelich’s future was very much in doubt.
During the first half of this season, Yelich has more than lived up to any expectations bestowed upon him. While he was not assured of being able to play every day, he has played in more games this season than he did all of last year. He has clobbered 16 home runs thus far, and his 60 RBI have him on pace to surpass the 110 runs he knocked in as an MVP in 2018.
That certainly checks the first box in Gonzalez’s piece.
Joey Ortiz Warming Up With The Weather For The Brewers
The second mention Gonzalez made to help the 2025 Brewers’ chances was how well Joey Ortiz replaced Willy Adames at shortstop. Adames, a fan favorite since arriving in May of 2021, belted 107 homers for the Brewers over his three and a half seasons in Milwaukee. During the off-season, he signed the richest free agent deal in San Francisco Giants history, inking a seven-year, $182 million deal in December.
That left Ortiz to fill Adames’ shoes at the shortstop position in 2025. Although his numbers in 2024 were fair (11 HRs, 60 RBI, .239 batting average), many doubted whether the second-year infielder was up to the task.
After a slow start through May in which he batted just .179, Ortiz has perked up once the calendar turned to June. In that month, he hit .277 (23-for-83) and contributed three homers and 13 RBI.
Those numbers as a shortstop, while pedestrian to those of superstars like Bobby Witt, Jr., and Trea Turner, are comparable to what Adames is doing in San Francisco this season. As of July 1, Ortiz is hitting .210 overall, and Adames comes in at .209.
Should Ortiz’ uptick continue, he will have more than stepped up in his efforts to replace Adames.
Megill Continues To Impress
Used primarily as an eighth-inning setup guy in 2024, Trevor Megill inherited the closer role upon the departure of Devin Williams to the New York Yankees. At the time, Williams and his vaunted “Airbender” changeup were thought to be indispensable at the end of the Brewers’ pitching lineup.
Williams saved 68 games for Milwaukee as the primary closer from 2022 through 2024. His last game as a Brewer, however, will forever haunt fans of the Crew. Up 2-1 in the ninth inning of the decisive Game 3 of the NL Wild Card round, Williams gave up a game-winning three-run home run to Pete Alonso of the New York Mets, thereby eliminating the Brewers.
Next up for the role was Megill, who has thrived in his new capacity. All he has done this year is record 18 saves, good for fourth in all of baseball, while sporting a 2.73 ERA.
In his first year in pinstripes, Williams has just 11 saves while posting a hefty 4.75 ERA.
End Of Brewers Rant: Questions Are Getting Answered Successfully
There is still a lot of baseball left to play in 2025, but if the first half is any indication, the Milwaukee Brewers have set themselves up for a solid chance at the playoffs. Alden Gonzalez did not know it at the time, but his article was spot on when discussing what hinged on the Brew Crew’s success.
Not mentioned in Gonzalez’s article but no less important is the way Milwaukee’s starting rotation has performed in light of devastating injuries. Brandon Woodruff has not pitched an inning for the Brewers this season, and Tobias Myers, last year’s breakout performer, has been limited to just six appearances. Despite those absences, Milwaukee currently owns the sixth-best team ERA (3.77) in the National League.
Once those regulars return, Milwaukee will have plenty of depth on its staff with which to play. Now that rookie Chad Patrick, journeyman Quinn Priester, and phenom Jacob Misiorowski are entrenched on the roster, the Brewers will soon enjoy an embarrassment of riches.
Christian Yelich is back doing Christian Yelich things, Joey Oritz is settling in nicely at shortstop, and Trevor Megill has stabilized the back end of Milwaukee’s pitching staff. If all three continue this trend, the rest of the National League Central will be forced to take heed of the Brewers this summer.