Toronto Blue Jays fans span far and wide across the massive country of Canada. They remain loyal and hopeful during this trying time of transition with the club. Those hopes have included various options for aggressively pursuing a talented 2025 free-agent class.

Club president and CEO Mark Shapiro, alongside his longtime sidekick and buddy, GM Ross Atkins, was said to have made a strong pitch and offer to Shohei Ohtani during the 2023 Winter Meetings. Rumors circulated of an offer to Japan’s superstar of 700 million dollars, well within the range of any other top offers that Ohtani’s camp might have been considering at the time.

Blue Jays fans thought they had him. Tales of Ohtani flying to Toronto in a private jet and his route being followed by fans were similar to any kid following the Santa tracker on Christmas Eve. Of course, it was not to be. Ohtani would sign a massive, deferred payment style deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers, historically dominating his DH role. His legacy in southern California and all over the world is now continuing to grow exponentially.

How Close Were They, Really??

The Toronto Blue Jays were also said to have been among the short list of potential clubs for Juan Soto. Again, Blue Jays faithfully stuck along for the ride but were ultimately disappointed, albeit this time not surprised. Their hopes became further deflated when other top-shelf free agents like Willie Adames, Corbin Burnes, Max Fried, and former Blue Jay Teoscar Hernandez began to fall off the board.

Come On Man, Horwitz?!?

Amid this frenzy of movement on the free agent market, Sapphiro and Atkins were able to swing a deal with their former club, the Cleveland Guardians. The Blue Jays parted ways with the hard-hitting Spencer Horwitz and prospects in exchange for former platinum glove winner second baseman Andres Gimenez.

What Happened??

Following that move, Shapiro and Atkins addressed some bullpen needs by signing former Jays setup man Yimi Garcia and proven late-inning, high-leverage pitcher Jeff Hoffman. These two additions will likely result in a competitive scenario for the open closer role among the two signees and veteran righty Chad Green. The front office seemed to hint that they were not done and were still actively pursuing available players.

So You’re Saying There Was A Chance?

Then came the much-anticipated announcement of where Japan’s rookie sensation Roki Sasaki would choose for his MLB destination. After apparently hosting Sasaki and his representatives in Toronto for a guided tour and conceivably leaving a pleasant impression on the young phenom, his small list of potential suitors was said to have included the Blue Jays.

On the day Sasaki was expected to announce, the Blue Jays first delivered a separate headline. They had acquired outfielder Myles Straw! Now again, Straw might be a wizard defensively in the outfield, much like his future teammate Daulton Varsho. However, like Varsho, Straw has a considerably low batting average and OPS.

Later in the day, news of Sasaki signing with the Dodgers added insult to injury. Sasaki would have been a nice addition to any club, but if there is one strong suit that has carried the Blue Jays at times over the past three seasons, it has been starting pitching. It isn’t a pressing need.

The agony the Blue Jays faithful has expressed has been applied to a trend that this front office has been showing for some time: They pursue players they cannot sign and acquire players who do not address their needs. Add to this the back-and-forth that Shapiro and Atkins have with their friends in Cleveland, and you have the Walmart version of what the Dodgers and Red Sox have been doing in recent years regarding exclusive trade relations.

End Of Rant

The most pressing need that faces the Blue Jays as they head into 2025 is hitting. They continue to imply that they depend solely on Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette’s production to contend. With both of these young All-Star players coming up for free agency in 2026, this is the final opportunity for the Blue Jays to assemble a strong supporting cast that might, by winning the division, entice them to stay in Toronto long-term.

Some big free-agent names are still available at this late stage of the offseason. If history is any indication though, all efforts to pursue them by the Blue Jays front office might only continue to provide Jays’ fans with false hope and frustration.

Read More MLB News From Stadium Rant Here: MLB News