The English League Cup (currently the Carabao Cup) is one of two English cups, alongside the FA Cup. Unlike the FA Cup, this cup does not include any non-league teams. It’s a smaller cup that includes teams from the Football League and the Premier League. The English League Cup dates back to the 1960s when the first League Cup games were played.
As English club grounds were gradually fitted with floodlights, it made midweek evening football possible throughout the winter months. The League Cup was first established specifically as a midweek floodlit soccer cup. To begin with, some teams from the higher leagues declined to play in it.
The first League Cup final played was Aston Villa vs. Rotherham in 1961. Then, it was a two-leg final that was played on a home-and-away basis. In the first final, Aston Villa emerged triumphant with a 3-0 win at Villa Park. Although they lost the first leg, with a 3-2 aggregate scoreline, they lifted the trophy after a terrific comeback.
The 1967 final was the first played at Wembley Stadium, by which time the League Cup also ensured European qualification for the winner. Gradually, all the Football League teams began to play in the League Cup. Despite going two goals down, QPR (Queen’s Park Rangers) still defeated West Brom 3-2 in that final. They were the first team from the third tier of English soccer to win the trophy in what was certainly an unexpected victory.
The 1977 League Cup final was played over three games. In this final, Everton and Aston Villa drew the first two finals, and so a second replay was played at Old Trafford. In this match, Villa triumphed with a late winner, sealing a 3-2 victory in a great League Cup final.
Liverpool established a stranglehold on the League Cup. During the 1980s, they dominated the cup, winning four League Cups from 1981 to 1984. That remains a record number of consecutive League Cups won, which Manchester City matched from 2018-2021.
Liverpool has won more League Cups than any other club, having won the competition 10 times to date. Liverpool were the first team to win the League Cup with a penalty shoot-out. That was against Birmingham City in the 2001 final. They also emerged triumphant with a penalty shoot-out victory against Cardiff after a 2-2 draw. Jürgen Klopp won the League Cup twice during his reign in the Anfield hot seat.
When Wembley Stadium was demolished, a new venue for the League Cup final was required. Instead of playing the final at English club stadiums, such as Old Trafford, the cup final was played outside England for the first time in 2001. Cardiff’s Millennium Stadium hosted a few League Cup finals until the New Wembley Stadium was opened.
France scrapped its League Cup in 2020, and some of the critics (such as UEFA president Aleksander Ceferin) have suggested England do the same. Yet, I, for one (and probably many other fans), would never want the League Cup scrapped. Although the Carabao Cup isn’t an especially lucrative soccer competition in terms of prize money and TV revenue, it is still a major trophy nonetheless. Scrapping the Carabao Cup would reduce the number of major trophies to play for in English football, making it harder for clubs to win serious silverware.
For example, winning the League Cup meant the world to Newcastle Utd in 2025. Newcastle would still be waiting decades to win a major trophy if there weren’t a Carabao Cup to play for. Hundreds of thousands of jubilant Geordies celebrated the Magpies’ League Cup bus parade in Tyneside. I doubt many of those fans who celebrated Carabao Cup glory would want the FA to scrap that trophy.
In more recent seasons, the bigger teams have generally fielded reserve (or younger) players in the early League Cup rounds and rotated their squads for some Carabao Cup matches. However, the League Cup should remain a notable cup in English soccer so long as it retains Europa League qualification for the teams that win it. It’s a cup that’s always had good entertainment value and given millions of English soccer fans plenty of memories.
If you love sports, download Stadium Rant from the Apple App Store and join one of the fastest-growing social sports communities. Be sure to follow us on socials too — you can find all our profiles on our Linktree.
