The fandom was irate when the New Orleans Saints drafted Tyler Shough in the second round (pick 40th overall). While he could become a long-term starter for the franchise, the concerns are warranted. Shough’s unique story likely pulled him off other teams’ draft boards.

College Was Strenuous For Tyler Shough

Shough has played through seven years of college eligibility, which is not a typo. Across those seven seasons, he spent time with Oregon, then Texas Tech, and most recently, Louisville in 2024. Speaking of his time in college, he is going to be playing alongside Saints tight end Juwan Johnson, a player with whom he was teammates at Oregon in 2018.

Of course, college athletes don’t just get to continue playing for no reason. Tyler Shough had suffered three severe injuries that continued to push his eligibility further back. He broke his collarbone, then rebroke it in each of his first two seasons at Texas Tech. On top of that, he suffered a broken fibula in 2023.

Now the concerns become valid when you put those injuries alongside the fact that he will be 26 at the start of the 2025 NFL season. This isn’t just a typical rookie quarterback. Then again, the scouts were falling in love with Shough during the pre-draft process.

Tyler Shough hopes to be the long-term answer at quarterback for the Saints
Tyler Shough hopes to be the long-term answer at quarterback for the Saints.

The Saints See The Positives

The fans might not like the decision to draft Shough, though management sees past his flaws. With new head coach Kellen Moore stepping in as the youngest head coach in the league, it made sense for New Orleans to target a quarterback. NFL franchises usually try to pair new head coaches with their chosen future quarterback.

General manager Mickey Loomis lauded Tyler Shough’s maturity despite the injuries that he’s suffered during his career. He noted that his experience at the position also helped their scouting process. Kellen Moore later stated that he’s already prepared to compete in the quarterback room.

Given the coaching staff’s trust and appreciation for Shough, it isn’t out of the question if he can start straight away in New Orleans. Quarterback Derek Carr is going through a ton outside of football, both with family and his shoulder. So there is no telling who might start under center at the beginning of next season. Perhaps Shough can be that guy.

Though Was An Early Draft Selection

Considering all of the concerns, it’s surprising that Tyler Shough was drafted in the second round at 40th overall. Even when considering that he’s “pro-ready”. A 26-year-old quarterback with numerous severe injuries isn’t usually taken right after the first round concludes. Usually these types of players go towards the end of the draft.

Shough was also the third quarterback drafted, behind the number one overall pick, Cam Ward, and 25th overall pick Jaxson Dart. That would be another reason for the fanbase’s outrage, with several other quarterbacks available.

With so much already invested in him, Shough will need to make an immediate impact. He can’t afford to waste any more time, given that he’ll be 30 by the end of his rookie contract. Plus, the Saints are in a rebuilding phase, so wasting second-round picks can’t happen.

Tyler Shough looks to be worthy of his second round draft selection
Tyler Shough looks to be worthy of his second-round draft selection.

Saints Have A Great Track Record With Second-Round Picks

Thankfully, the Saints were incredibly good at drafting talent in the second round. Every single second-round draft pick from 2016 to 2024 has received significant playing time (outside of Isaiah Foskey, who was taken in 2023).

Among the most notable names are wide receiver Michael Thomas, safety Marcus Williams, center Erik McCoy, cornerback Alontae Taylor, and linebacker Pete Werner. Even their most recent second-round pick, Kool-Aid McKinstry, is anticipated to play a large role in 2025.

Here’s to hoping that this magic can be maintained with Shough.

End Of My Tyler Shough Rant

Mickey Loomis mentioned that if Derek Carr is available and healthy, he’ll be the starter in New Orleans. If that is the case, we won’t be seeing Shough anytime soon. With Carr’s status incredibly murky, right now, the job is open.

Tyler Shough will likely need to battle it out with Jake Haener and Spencer Rattler throughout training camp. Most signs point towards Haener being the odd man out, but he’ll have his chance to prove that he belongs.

In the meantime, all Saints fans can do is sit back and hope the coaching staff knows what they’re doing. This team cannot afford another missed quarterback opportunity, nor can they waste valuable draft picks.