The Toronto Maple Leafs and the Ottawa Senators are separated by a roughly 4-hour stretch of uncinematic highway. Toronto, as the capital of Ontario and  Canada’s largest city, is the Mecca of hockey. A city that rides the emotional roller coaster of hope and heartbreak each and every season. Leaf fans are once again on their high horse of false hope, after another successful regular season run that culminated with an Atlantic Division title.

Ottawa is Canada’s capital, and during the current tumultuous era of tariff-riding rhetoric that dominates headlines and aims to demean Canadian heritage, it is the center of National pride. Amid political uncertainty and transition, the capital city, a bilingual hub in the hockey world, is very familiar with the “underdog” label. 

The Sens have been in the NHL basement for some time. Unlike the Leafs, though, when the Sens make it into the Stanley Cup playoffs, they make a run. They grind and leave nothing on the ice. Most recently, in the 2017 playoffs, the Senators entered the dance as the sixth seed in the Eastern Conference. Plowing clear past the upstart Boston Bruins team in six games, where all but one game went to overtime. Round two was also a thriller, as the Sens eliminated the New York Rangers, again in six games. 

They were a team of young, hungry, elite skaters, led by All-World defenceman Erik Karlsson. In the Eastern Conference final, the Senators battled Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and the mighty Pittsburgh Penguins, taking the series to double overtime in Game 7. That playoff run wasn’t quite as dominant as the Sens’ 2006-2007 Stanley Cup finals appearance, but it instilled a true sense of pride in the team. As a smaller market franchise, the Ottawa Senators have exceeded all expectations and reaffirmed their presence in the NHL as a team to be reckoned with.

The Leafs have not had that same reputation or aura surrounding them as they enter the playoffs, since 2004. The fanbase of that storied franchise has come to expect failure. The last true glimmer of hope and optimism during a playoff run occurred in 2004, when, fittingly, the Leafs fought, grinded, and ultimately emerged from round one by beating the Senators in seven games. It would be 20 years until the Leafs would ever make it through to the second round again. 

Historic Rivalry

The rivalry in 2004 was legendary, and the faces of both teams are deeply ingrained in the memories of even the most casual hockey fan who resided anywhere in Ontario at that time. Two of the greatest players ever to come out of Sweden, Mats Sundin of the Leafs and Daniel Alfredsson of the Senators, were both in their prime and at the peak of their extreme skill levels. Enforcers Tie Domi and Chris Neil would taunt one another from the bench and in the corners, to stir up emotion and sway momentum by dropping the gloves. The ‘04 series was a classic.

The New NHL

The game has changed. In many ways, for the better, but the physicality or plain brute violence that previous generations might have become used to witnessing in a round one playoff series is likely not to occur nearly to the same extent. Fittingly, Brady Tkachuk, the antagonist during the 4-Nations Face-Off, pre-whistle Donny Brook, will be about the only pest that is truly expected to drop the gloves at any given moment.

Sens coach Travis Green is undoubtedly taking all preventative measures to try to calm down the fiery captain, so that his high-tempo playmaking ability isn’t reserved for 5-minute majors and game misconducts. Tkachuk will get in the mix and jab away at superstars Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner, but he is no Chris Neil.

End Of Battle Of Ontario Rant:

Fans like me, who are looking for old-time hockey with both teams leaving the ice battered, bruised, and hobbling after seven games, might be disappointed. The series will go seven games, and the Senators are the hungrier and more driven of the two. Leafs fans are dying for a playoff run of substance. One that will go down in the history of the original six franchises as one of their all-time best. They are doomed if they look ahead and too far past the Ottawa Senators. This series will highlight the exceptional skating and playmaking abilities of today’s NHL players. The Leafs will emerge and advance, but just barely. Leafs in seven!