The Indiana Pacers defeated the New York Knicks 125-108 on Saturday to advance to the 2025 NBA Finals. Indiana point guard Tyrese Haliburton had 21 points, six rebounds, 13 assists, three steals, and one block in the game. Haliburton has largely been the face of the Pacers for the past few seasons, so when they have won, he has been given the lion’s share of the credit. When they have lost, like when he had only eight points in Game Five of the series, he has also received the lion’s share of the blame.

After Game Five, social media and sports talk was flooded with talk about how Haliburton is not a superstar, but those critics found stiff opposition to those views from his fans. So, is Tyrese Haliburton a legit NBA superstar? The debate will rage on throughout the NBA Finals, which start on Thursday, June 5. There is a good chance that the debate will continue through next season. This article will examine both sides of the debate.

The Case For Tyrese Haliburton

There is no debate that Tyrese Haliburton is a star in the NBA. The 25-year-old point guard has been an NBA All-Star twice, and he was voted Third-Team All-NBA twice, as well. He led the NBA in assists during the 2023-2024 season. He has averaged 17.5 points, 3.7 rebounds, 8.8 assists, 1.5 steals, and 0.6 blocks for his young career, while only turning the ball over 2.1 times per game. Haliburton’s playoff numbers are almost identical. He had a career-high 23 assists in a 2023 game against the rival Knicks. During that same season he scored a career-high 44 points against the Heat and 43 points against the Hornets.

What critics underestimate about Tyrese Haliburton is his ability to make plays and spread the ball around. The Pacers had seven players average double-figure points this season. They had nine players average double-figures during the previous season. Haliburton finds everyone, and he makes those passes without turning the ball over. He ranks at or near the top of the league every season in assist-to-turnover ratio. Haliburton also has a penchant for hitting clutch shots at the end of games.

The Case Against Tyrese Haliburton

Many of the same stats that prove that Haliburton is a star also work against him in the superstar debate. Indiana plays a team game. They spread the ball around. As stated above, the team routinely has seven players scoring in double figures. Haliburton is one of them, but for the last two seasons, it has been power forward Pascal Siakam who has led the team in scoring. It has also been Siakam who led the team in rebounds per game both seasons, but no one is talking about Siakam as a superstar.

One could argue that the Pacers’ team does not have a superstar, and that they have been very successful without one. They made it to the Eastern Conference Finals last season and the finals this season. Haliburton, Siakam, Miles Turner, Benedict Mathurin, and the rest have all played their parts. Haliburton had a big game in the final game of the Knicks’ series last weekend, but he was not the leading scorer in the game. Again, that player was Siakam, who scored 31 points, added five rebounds, three assists, one steal, and three blocks.

When one thinks of an NBA superstar right now, they think of high-profile standouts who dominate their team’s stat sheets. LeBron James, Giannis Antetokounmpo, Nikola Jokić, Stephen Curry–these are NBA superstars. These are the names synonymous with the sport. These are the faces you see plastered everywhere. Tyrese Haliburton has not yet hit that level, and the Pacers have not needed him to. Maybe they will need that in the upcoming NBA Finals. Only time will tell.

Tyrese Haliburton is becoming a superstar in the NBA

End Of My Tyrese Haliburton Superstar Rant

Tyrese Haliburton is, no doubt, a star. Is he a superstar? –Not yet. That name and face recognition just isn’t there yet with the casual NBA fan. That said, if he dominates the NBA Finals against the Oklahoma City Thunder, I think the consensus will finally be in his favor. If Haliburton played on 65 percent of the other teams in the NBA, he probably would have already achieved that status. On a team constructed like the Pacers, where 7-10 people make major contributions every night, Haliburton does not need to be a superstar.

So, right now, no, Tyrese Haliburton is not an NBA superstar, and that’s okay. The Pacers have not needed him to be one. They have built their franchise as a team-oriented, anyone-can-beat-you-on-any-given-night kind of team. That is the same formula that the South Carolina women’s college basketball team has ridden to five Final Fours and three National Championships in the last eight seasons — team first. That was the formula for the “Bad Boys” era of the Detroit Pistons–defense-oriented teams with balanced offensive attacks.

Haliburton will have plenty of time to gain that status, and he most likely will. He just hasn’t yet. Again, that is okay. The Pacers organization does not seem to be complaining, so you shouldn’t be either. The way the business end of the NBA is right now, Haliburton will most likely find himself on a team (Indiana or otherwise) someday that needs him to be that stand-out, face-of-the-franchise, do-everything guy. When that time comes, my money is on him taking that next step. In fact, I look forward to it.