Utility Players have filled important roles on MLB rosters for some time now. The former 2016 World Series Champion Chicago Cubs manager Joe Madden once said, “A good utility player is like having an extra coach on the field. They understand the game at a high level and can adapt to any situation.”
Madden’s former All-Star Utility man Ben Zobrist comes to mind as the prototype player who fits this description. A player who can be penciled into the lineup at any and all positions if called upon to do so.
The Ability To Play All Positions

All managers, from beer league softball to fantasy and every level up to The Show, will appreciate a player who can compete with a high level of efficiency across the diamond. Typically, a player who rises through the ranks of professional baseball was probably a shortstop at some point in their journey. For left-handed throwers, the extent of their versatility was probably limited to first base and outfield.
Still, players with multiple position eligibilities tend to share common attributes: great athleticism and the ability to hit. Hitting is what keeps the utility man in the lineup every day.
The Valued Utility Player

What makes them unique is the element of choice that they offer managers, which makes them good enough to start at any position where there is an area of need. As for fantasy managers, these players might carry ADPs that are way down the list of your possible draft options. In a Roto league though, where you carry up to 14 players on any given day, it would be wise to have one of these on standby. They will provide the stats that will sustain your position in your league if they need to be penciled in at any position where they are eligible.
The following players will offer eligibility at multiple positions, and they just might earn enough points to steal a win here and there in your head-to-head matchups. These players will also carry their weight in a category league.
Jazz Chisholm, Yankees

Yankees manager Aaron Boone has indicated that Chisholm will begin the year as the team’s regular second baseman. It is rather easy to imagine that he could start on occasion at third, as that remains an area of need in the Bronx. He could potentially step over to shortstop and, more likely, the outfield if called upon, thereby considerably extending his eligible positions in fantasy leagues. It may take a while to see just how versatile Chisholm can be for the Yankees, but patience will pay off.
Joey Ortiz, Brewers

Ortiz is listed as the starting third baseman for the Crew. Milwaukee should be fairly secure with Brice Turang as their starting shortstop now, but Ortiz is very capable of filling in at times. Ortiz’s bat will ensure that he’s in the lineup every day. His power plus speed ability, which several players in the Brewers lineup also have, should result in a 20-20 season.
Jonathan India, Royals

The Royals have placed high expectations of India’s ability to produce as an offensive catalyst and a durable defender. Having sent reliable starting pitcher Brady Singer to the Reds, Kansas City is hoping that India hasn’t yet fully reached his potential. As the fifth overall pick in the 2018 draft, India soared to a 20-plus home run and 800-plus OPS in his rookie season of 2021. He should see time all over the infield and will likely earn eligibility at any defensive position that isn’t assigned to Salvador Perez or Bobby Witt Jr.
Kike Hernandez, Dodgers

The Dodgers rewarded Kike Hernandez’s phenomenal utility performance in the ‘24 postseason by bringing him back for 2025. We are all aware of this and have seen the 33-year-old Dodger mainstay play all over the field, including as a pitcher in the odd debacle or blowout game.
The only downside of taking Kike as your fantasy utility option is the question of playing time. Hernandez’s playing time was sufficient enough through the year in 2024 to allow for him to be included on, say, a 14-man Roto categories roster. 2025 is a different beast altogether, as the Dodgers are even more stacked. Kike will get his playing time, but probably not as much as he is accustomed to having.
Matt Vierling, Tigers

Tigers manager A.J. Hinch has an abundance of players who can be assigned to a variety of positions. Matt Vierling will likely become position-eligible at first, third, and the outfield. He showed serious pop last September in helping the Tigers push toward the playoffs. Vierling’s home run total has steadily climbed from season to season, and at the age of 28, he seems poised to ride the Tigers’ wave of success. A 25 home run season isn’t out of the question for this valuable and versatile player.
Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Pirates

There seems to have always been a general undermining and, at times, flat-out disrespect toward IKF’s abilities and what he brings to the team. His offensive metrics are about as steady and predictably solid as those of any player who might be deemed “utility.” His gold glove was awarded while with Texas, and he has started for some time as the Yankees’ shortstop.
IKF will begin 2025 as the Pirates shortstop, but if Ke’Bryan Hayes is removed from the lineup at any time, IKF could slide over to third. There is plenty of experimentation and transient movement of projected starting players for Pittsburgh. This could mean that IKF will become eligible for almost every position in the field. He will play, and his numbers will surprise some people.
Ernie Clement, Blue Jays

The Blue Jays are toying with the idea of having young slugger Orvelis Martinez penciled in as their third baseman. This shouldn’t mean that Clement won’t get his regular playing time, as he has proven to be too valuable to sit out. Clement’s defense is elite, and he will hit double digits in home runs and stolen bases. If Bo Bichette is moved or on the IL, Clement and Andres Gimenez will make for a solid middle infield. He’ll make the odd appearance in left field as well.
Connor Norby, Marlins

In 2024, Norby offered a glimpse of the projected high ceiling that has followed him since his early days in the Orioles system. The 24-year-old is heading into camp with the idea of being the Marlins third baseman of the future. The team though, has a lot of uncertainty in terms of positional players.
This fact should imply that Norby will gain positional eligibility all over the infield and possibly into the outfield. The Marlins are not expected to compete for a playoff spot, but Norby could elevate his stock as a potential All-Star. With regular playing time, a 20-20 season should be in his near future.
Paul DeJong, Nationals

DeJong has been quite the journeyman these past two seasons. He has played for five different clubs as a valued utility player. His role was often to fill in for injured regulars, such as his stint in Toronto, where he played shortstop in place of the injured Bo Bichette. The fact remains that aside from being eligible to play anywhere on the field, DeJong is a home run hitter. Having hit 24 last season and 30 in 2019, DeJong has the right amount of pop to start if needed.
The Nationals seem fairly secure in their infield configuration, and DeJong will serve as a utility player who comes off of the bench to pinch hit or as a defensive replacement. If he is underutilizing, the Nats could again shop DeJong around. No matter what level of playing time awaits DeJong, he is known as an asset to any team with him on their roster.
Brandon Lowe, Rays

There is much to Lowe’s game that is comparable to Ben Zobrist’s. A high baseball IQ and a power bat, either starting at second or first base, depending on who is on the IL. Lowe will find time in the outfield if needed, but his role with the Rays in ‘25 should be at DH, first base on occasion, and second base as the usual starter. Fantasy managers will hope for at least a game in the outfield in order to offer up Lowe as a utility option for the outfield as well as the right side of the infield. He has 25-30 home run potential if he stays in the lineup every day.
End Of My Utility Player Rant

The utility player is an important draft piece to consider, depending on the format of your fantasy league. As fans, we have seen so many iconic moments in recent baseball history where a utility player has come up clutch in a high-pressure moment. They provide versatility for the teams that have them and options for managers who must fill a lineup with capable players.
Read More MLB News From Stadium Rant Here: MLB News